Themes

What is thematic investing? Meaning, risks and how to cap a theme

Written by

Reviewed by

Arpit AgarwalCharvi AgarwalThe Amaltash Team

Updated ยท Published

The short answer. Thematic investing means buying companies tied to one big story, like AI or nuclear power. A theme holds only the companies that fit the story, while an S&P 500 fund holds about 500. So it can fall further than the market. A cap limits how much money it holds.

How big should one position be?

$
%
%

A stop is not a guarantee: prices can gap past it.

Per position
$5,000
Full-size positions that fit
10
At risk per position
$5,000
At risk, share of portfolio
10.00%
Position$5,000
At risk$5,000

Hypothetical illustration based on your inputs. Not a prediction, a recommendation, or the performance of any Amaltash strategy.

Turn this into a rule

Hold my chosen theme at no more than 10% of my portfolio. If the theme falls 25% from its high, move that slice to T-Bills and alert me.
Cap a theme with a rule

Opens the Strategy Builder with this rule filled in. It starts building after a 3-second countdown; type to stop it. Nothing trades until you deploy.

What is thematic investing?

Thematic investing means picking investments by a story about the future. "Data centers need more power" is one story. It can turn into a list of power companies, uranium miners and reactor makers.

A broad fund, like one that follows the S&P 500, owns about 500 large US companies. It owns what the market owns. A theme owns only what the story says matters.

That is the whole appeal and the whole risk. If the story comes true before prices catch up, a theme can move very differently from the market. But the story can be late or wrong, or prices may already count on it. Then the theme can fall while the market holds up.

This page covers what a theme is and how it can go wrong. For five current stories and how each can fail, see our thematic investing examples.

Thematic investing strategies: three ways to hold a theme

There are three common ways to hold a theme. Each one has its own costs and risks, so check them before you start.

Three ways to hold a theme

Way What it is What to check
A theme fund (ETF) One fund that holds a basket of theme companies. It trades on an exchange, like a stock. What it holds, how many companies, and its yearly fee
Your own basket You pick and buy the companies yourself. How much rides on one company, plus trading costs and taxes
A rule-based strategy Written rules pick the companies and trim them back on a schedule. The rules, and what happens when they sell

How is thematic investing different from sector investing?

A sector fund follows a standard list of industries. A theme follows a story, and the story can cross many industries.

The most used list is called GICS. MSCI built it with S&P Dow Jones Indices in 1999. As of August 2024, it sorts companies into 11 sectors, like energy and health care.

A nuclear power theme can hold utilities, uranium miners and makers of reactor parts. GICS puts those in different sectors. So a theme is not a sector, even when it sounds like one.

Broad fund, sector fund or theme: how each one picks

Question Broad index fund Sector fund Theme
Picks companies by Their size in the market A standard industry list A story about the future
Example S&P 500: about 500 large US companies Energy, one of 11 GICS sectors Nuclear power, across several sectors
A main risk The whole market falls Bad news for one industry The story is late, wrong or already in the price

Source: S&P 500 size: S&P Dow Jones Indices. GICS sectors: MSCI GICS Methodology, August 2024.

Why is thematic investing risky?

Thematic investing is risky because it puts a lot of money into a few related companies. FINRA, which oversees US brokers, calls this concentration risk. It describes it as "the risk of amplified losses."

The companies in a theme often share the same buyers, the same rules and the same news. So they can fall together. Themes also often hold young or small companies, whose prices swing more.

Themes get popular after a run of good news. By then, prices may already count on the story coming true. So a theme can fall further than the market and stay down longer.

None of this means a theme is off limits. It means you decide how big it can get before you buy, while you are calm.

Does thematic investing work?

Research gives a warning. A 2023 study in The Review of Financial Studies looked at narrow, specialized ETFs. Many of them follow popular themes. Over their first five years, they lost about 30% after adjusting for risk.

The study says high fees did not explain this. Instead, the stocks inside were overpriced when the funds launched.

That is an average across many funds. It does not tell you how any one theme will do. But it is a good reason to keep a theme small and set its limits first.

How do you cap a theme?

You cap a theme with two rules, set before you buy. A cap is the most of your money one theme can hold. A drawdown limit says what happens if the theme falls a set amount from its high.

A drawdown limit works like a stop-loss for a whole theme. When it is hit, the rule sells. The money moves to cash or Treasury Bills, which are short loans to the US government.

Here is some made-up math. Say a theme is capped at 10% of your money. The rule sells it after a 25% fall from its high. Then the planned loss is about 2.5% of everything you have.

Prices can jump past a limit, so the real loss can be bigger. Treat the limit as a plan, not a floor. The calculator on this page lets you try your own numbers.

  1. Pick the cap: the most of your money the theme may hold, like 5% or 10%.
  2. Pick the drawdown limit: how far the theme may fall from its high, like 20% or 30%.
  3. Pick where the money goes, like cash or T-Bills, and when you would buy back.
  4. Pick when to trim it back: on a set date, or when it grows past its cap.

Planned loss from one theme = cap x drawdown limit (made-up math, not a forecast)

Cap Drawdown limit Planned loss of all your money
5% 20% about 1%
10% 25% about 2.5%
15% 30% about 4.5%

Source: Simple math: cap times limit. Prices can jump past a limit, so a real loss can be bigger.

Core and satellite: where a theme fits

One common way to hold themes is called core and satellite. The core is a broad, low-cost fund, and it holds most of your money. The satellites are small, capped themes around it.

Trimming means selling some of a theme to bring it back to its cap. Say a theme doubles while the rest of your money stays flat. A 10% slice grows to about 18%, and nobody chose that.

A trim on a set date, or when the theme passes a set size, brings it back. Selling to trim can mean a tax bill.

How Amaltash handles themes

Amaltash lists theme strategies on its marketplace, like nuclear power, the space economy, GLP-1 drugs and gold. Each one is a set of written rules you can read before you turn it on.

You can add your own cap and drawdown limit in plain English. When the limit is hit, the rule moves that slice to T-Bills.

A guardrail limits a loss. It does not stop one. Prices can jump past a limit overnight, and a rule can sell just before prices bounce back.

Selling in a taxable account can mean a tax bill. Investing involves risk, including the loss of principal.

Risks and limits

  • A theme is concentrated: its holdings often fall together, and it can drop further and stay down longer than a broad index.
  • The story can be right and the investment still lose money, if prices already reflect it.
  • A drawdown limit can be skipped past in a price gap, and it can sell just before a rebound.
  • Selling to enforce a cap or a limit can create a tax bill in a taxable account.
  • Investing involves risk, including the loss of principal.

Frequently asked questions

What is a thematic ETF?

It is a fund that holds companies tied to one theme. Its shares trade on a stock exchange, like a stock. Check what it holds, how many companies it holds, and its yearly fee.

Is thematic investing the same as ESG investing?

No. ESG investing picks companies by how they treat the planet and people, and how they are run. Thematic investing picks companies by a story about the future. A clean energy fund can be both.

How much of a portfolio should go into themes?

There is no single right number. It depends on your goals, your time frame and how much loss you can take. The calculator on this page shows what a cap means in dollars.

Can a drawdown limit stop all losses from a theme?

No. Prices can jump past the limit, so the sale can happen lower. The rule can also sell just before prices bounce back. It plans your loss ahead of time, but it is not a promise.

Does Amaltash pick themes for me?

No. You choose the strategy and the rules. Amaltash runs the rules you approve, including any cap or drawdown limit. You can read the rules in plain English before you start.

Sources

Share this article

Educational content published by Amaltash Advisors LLC. Nothing here is investment advice or a recommendation to buy or sell any security. All investing involves risk of loss, including loss of principal, and past performance does not guarantee future results.

Get started