Robo-advisors and automation

AI investing: what AI investing apps and tools actually do (and what they can’t)

Written by

Reviewed by

Arpit AgarwalCharvi AgarwalThe Amaltash Team

Updated · Published

The short answer. AI investing means using AI to research, manage or trade investments. In apps and tools, the AI usually does one of four jobs: chat, predict prices, automate tasks or turn your words into rules. Each can fail, and no app can promise returns. Check the firm is registered first.

How big should one position be?

$
%
%

A stop is not a guarantee: prices can gap past it.

Per position
$5,000
Full-size positions that fit
10
At risk per position
$5,000
At risk, share of portfolio
10.00%
Position$5,000
At risk$5,000

Hypothetical illustration based on your inputs. Not a prediction, a recommendation, or the performance of any Amaltash strategy.

Turn this into a rule

Hold SPY. If SPY falls 15% from its 52-week high, move half of the position to T-Bills. Buy back when SPY closes above its 200-day moving average.
Turn this into a rule

Opens the Strategy Builder with this rule filled in. It starts building after a 3-second countdown; type to stop it. Nothing trades until you deploy.

What is AI investing?

AI investing means using artificial intelligence to research, manage or trade investments. It runs inside AI investing apps and tools, from chat helpers to software that builds a whole portfolio.

People also say “AI investing” when they mean buying shares of companies that build AI. That is a theme, a different idea with its own risks, covered in our guide to thematic investing. This page is about investing with AI.

Inside AI investing apps and tools, the AI usually does one of four jobs. It chats, it predicts, it automates, or it turns your words into rules. Each job can fail in its own way. Knowing the job tells you what to ask. The table is a map, not a review of any app.

The four jobs AI does in AI investing apps and tools, and their limits

Job What it does What it cannot do What to check
Chat Answers questions about markets, terms and your account Always be right; know your whole money picture Whether answers show sources; whether the firm is registered
Predict Guesses prices, trends or risk from past data Stay right when markets change How it was tested on data it never saw
Automate Rebalances, moves cash or sells losers for taxes on a schedule Decide what your target mix should be Fees, triggers and how often it trades
Translate Turns your plain-English idea into exact trading rules Know whether your idea is a good one Whether you can read and change every rule before it runs

Source: Our own grouping. FINRA’s June 2020 report on AI sorts its uses into customer communications, investment processes and operational functions.

Does AI investing work?

AI investing works for some jobs, like explaining a term or following a rule. No AI reliably predicts the market. Markets change, and a model that learned from the past can stop working.

Regulators say the same. The SEC, NASAA and FINRA put out a joint alert on January 25, 2024. Information from AI “can be faulty, or even completely made up,” the alert says. That can happen even when the data going in is right.

So ask which job the AI does, and how you can check its work.

Is AI trading the same as AI investing?

Not quite. AI trading usually means software that picks and places trades on its own, often called a trading bot. AI investing is wider. It also covers chat helpers, robo-advisors and rule builders for money you plan to hold for years.

Is AI trading legit? Using AI to trade is legal in the US, but “AI trading” is also a common hook for scams. On January 25, 2024, the CFTC warned that “AI technology can’t predict the future or sudden market changes.” It called claims of high or guaranteed returns red flags of fraud.

The same day, the SEC, NASAA and FINRA warned about unregistered platforms selling AI trading systems. Their alert quotes claims like “Our proprietary AI trading system can’t lose!” No AI trading system can promise a profit.

AI trading can lose money, like any trading. A bot can also repeat a bad trade many times before you notice. So read its rules, check who is registered, and test with paper trading first.

Rules-based investing: where AI writes the rules

Rules-based investing means you decide ahead of time what you will buy, sell or hold, and when. Then you follow those rules instead of guessing in the moment. “Keep each holding under 10% of the account” is a rule. “Sell if it feels risky” is not.

Rules help because the hardest choices come at the worst times, like in a fast drop. A rule you wrote while calm does not panic. But it also does not adapt. A rule that fits one market can be wrong for the next.

AI changes who can write rules. Exact rules used to need code. Now a language model can turn a sentence into steps a computer can follow. For example: if the S&P 500 falls 15% from its high, move half to T-Bills.

One real pipeline: plain English to rules to guardrails

Here is how Amaltash’s Strategy Builder works today. It is one example of the “translate” job. Other apps work differently.

  1. You describe an idea in plain English. Name the stock or fund, when to buy and when to sell. Say how much risk you accept.
  2. The engine writes it as exact rules for buying, selling and how much to hold. It adds guardrails, which are limits like a stop-loss, a take-profit, a drawdown limit or a sector cap.
  3. You read the rules and change them by chatting. One sentence can be turned into rules in more than one way, so this step matters.
  4. You can backtest the rules on past US stock and ETF prices. You can also paper trade them, which uses no real money.
  5. You turn the rules on only when you choose. Then they run on their own, guardrails included, until you change or stop them.

What no AI investing app or tool can do

No app can promise a return or promise you will not lose money. The 2024 alert says to be wary of claims, “even from registered firms and professionals,” that AI can guarantee amazing investment returns.

Some real firms have overstated their AI, too. On March 18, 2024, the SEC charged two advisers over false claims about their use of AI. They agreed to pay $400,000 in penalties in total. The SEC called this “AI washing.”

No model reliably predicts a stock market crash, or the bounce after one. Models learn from the past, and markets change in ways the past did not show.

No guardrail removes risk. A stop-loss can sell well below its trigger when a price gaps overnight. A drawdown limit acts only after some loss has already happened.

And no app knows your whole money life unless you tell it. Taxes, debts, timelines and other accounts change what makes sense for you.

How to check an AI investing app before you use it

Scams that use the word “AI” are common, so check before you sign up.

Using AI does not change the rules a firm must follow. In June 2024, FINRA said its rules “continue to apply” when firms use generative AI. These checks work for any app, including ours.

  1. Ask which of the four jobs the AI does. If the app cannot say, be careful.
  2. Look up the firm on Investor.gov or adviserinfo.sec.gov. You will see if it is registered and any past trouble with regulators.
  3. Read its Form CRS and Form ADV Part 2A. They list fees, conflicts and any past discipline.
  4. Check that you can read the exact rules or holdings before any money moves.
  5. Test with paper trading or a small amount first.
  6. Find out who holds your money. Look for a regulated custodian and SIPC membership.
  7. Add up the total cost: app fees, fund fees and trading costs.

Risks and limits

  • The model can be wrong. AI can misread an instruction or produce a confident, incorrect answer.
  • Forecasts break. Models trained on past data can fail when market conditions change.
  • Backtests can be overfit or contain look-ahead bias, making a rule look better in testing than it will be live.
  • Past results, real or simulated, do not predict future results.
  • Guardrails reduce but cannot eliminate the risk of loss. You can lose money, including more than a stop level suggests when prices gap.

Frequently asked questions

Can AI predict the stock market?

Not reliably. Models find patterns in past prices, but markets change and patterns fade. The 2024 SEC, NASAA and FINRA alert warns against relying only on AI to make investing choices.

What are AI investing tools?

AI investing tools are apps or features that use AI for one investing job. Examples are chat helpers, price forecasts, automatic rebalancing and rule builders. They help you research or act, but they do not remove the risk of loss.

Is an AI trading bot the same as an AI investing app?

Not always. A trading bot places trades on its own, while many investing apps only chat, suggest or rebalance on a schedule. Either way, check that the firm behind it is registered and that you can see what it will do before it trades.

Can beginners use an AI investing app?

Yes, but start small. Use paper trading or a small amount, and read what the app will do before it trades. Make sure the firm behind it is registered.

Can you lose money with AI investing?

Yes. All investing can lose money, and AI adds the risk that the model is wrong. Guardrails can limit a loss, but prices can jump past them.

Is there an AI investing app?

Yes, many investing apps now use AI, and some are run by registered advisers. One kind is a robo-advisor, which is usually a registered adviser. Search any firm’s name on adviserinfo.sec.gov before you use it.

Sources

Share this article

Educational content published by Amaltash Advisors LLC. Nothing here is investment advice or a recommendation to buy or sell any security. All investing involves risk of loss, including loss of principal, and past performance does not guarantee future results.

Get started