Downside protection
Sequence of returns risk: what it is, with a worked example
Written by
Founder & CEO
Amaltash Research
Amaltash Advisors LLC
Reviewed by
Arpit AgarwalCharvi AgarwalThe Amaltash Team
Updated ยท Published
The short answer. Sequence of returns risk is the risk that losses arrive just as you start taking money out. In our made-up example, two retirees earn the same 3% average return. The one with losses first is $112,070 behind after five years. Selling shares low leaves less to recover.
Same returns, different order
An editable example, not a forecast. Separate years with commas. Withdrawals come out at the start of each year.
- Ending balance, your order
- $366,954
- Ending balance, reversed order
- $443,515
- Your order
- Lasted all years
- Reversed order
- Lasted all years
Hypothetical illustration based on your inputs. Not a prediction, a recommendation, or the performance of any Amaltash strategy.
Turn this into a rule
Keep two years of my planned withdrawals in T-Bills. If my stock funds fall 20% from their high, pay withdrawals from T-Bills only and move stocks back toward target after 10 trading days above the 50-day average.Build a withdrawal-year rule
Opens the Strategy Builder with this rule filled in. It starts building after a 3-second countdown; type to stop it. Nothing trades until you deploy.
What is sequence of returns risk?
Sequence of returns risk, also called sequence risk, is about order. The order of your returns, not just their average, decides how long your money lasts. It matters when you take money out. That is why it comes up most in retirement.
The cause is simple. To pay the bills, a retiree sells shares. If prices are down, more shares must be sold for the same dollars. Those shares are gone when prices recover, so the account climbs back from a smaller base.
It is not the same as market risk. Market risk is the chance that prices fall. Sequence risk is the extra harm a fall does because of when it happens.
Two people in the same fund face the same market risk. If only one is withdrawing, only that one faces sequence risk.
Order does not matter until money moves
With no money going in or out, order makes no difference. Multiplying returns gives the same answer in any order. Take $1,000,000 that earns -20%, -10%, +10%, +15% and +20% over five years. It ends at $1,092,960 whichever way round those years come.
Now take out $50,000 at the start of each year, and the answer changes. So an average return can fool anyone who plans to take money out. The average describes the whole trip, not the order of the stops.
Worked example: same returns, opposite order
Two retirees each start with $1,000,000. Each takes out $50,000 at the start of every year. Both earn the same five made-up returns, which average 3% a year. Retiree A gets the losses first, and Retiree B gets them last.
Year-end balances after a $50,000 start-of-year withdrawal (made-up returns)
| Year | A: return | A: balance | B: return | B: balance |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | -20% | $760,000 | +20% | $1,140,000 |
| 2 | -10% | $639,000 | +15% | $1,253,500 |
| 3 | +10% | $647,900 | +10% | $1,323,850 |
| 4 | +15% | $687,585 | -10% | $1,146,465 |
| 5 | +20% | $765,102 | -20% | $877,172 |
Source: Arithmetic on made-up returns to show the effect of order. Not market data, a forecast, or the record of any strategy.
What the example shows
Both took out the same $250,000 and earned the same returns. Yet B ends with $112,070 more than A. A sold shares at low prices in years 1 and 2. So the strong years 4 and 5 worked on a smaller balance.
Change the withdrawal and the gap moves, as the table below shows. With no withdrawals, there is no gap. The withdrawal is the lever you control; the order of returns is not.
Over a 30-year retirement the effect can be larger. A poor start shrinks the base that every later year grows from. So the years just before and after you retire are often called the retirement risk zone.
Real falls can be deeper than this made-up one. The S&P 500 is about 500 large US companies, tracked as one number. It fell 56.8% from October 2007 to March 2009, by daily closing prices. It did not regain its 2007 high until March 2013.
Ending balance after five years: the same made-up returns, four yearly withdrawals
| Yearly withdrawal | A: losses first | B: losses last | Gap |
|---|---|---|---|
| $0 | $1,092,960 | $1,092,960 | $0 |
| $25,000 | $929,031 | $985,066 | $56,035 |
| $50,000 | $765,102 | $877,172 | $112,070 |
| $75,000 | $601,173 | $769,278 | $168,105 |
Source: Arithmetic on made-up returns to show the effect of order. Not market data, a forecast, or the record of any strategy.
Sequence of returns risk in retirement: who is exposed
Anyone who takes money out on a schedule. That includes retirees living on savings and people living off investments between jobs. Funds with a fixed yearly payout face it too. The bigger the withdrawal compared with the balance, the bigger the risk.
Savers face the mirror image. When you add money, poor early returns mean your deposits buy at lower prices. For savers, a bad stretch just before withdrawals start hurts most. That is when the balance is largest.
How do you reduce sequence of returns risk?
You can reduce it, but not remove it. Each way below moves the risk around or trades it for a different cost.
A reserve can be a savings account or a T-Bill ladder that comes due on a schedule.
Common ways to reduce sequence risk, and what each costs
| Approach | How it works | Cost |
|---|---|---|
| Cash or T-Bill reserve | Hold one to three years of withdrawals outside stocks and spend from it in down years | That money earns short-term interest, which can trail stocks and inflation |
| Flexible withdrawals | Spend less in years after a fall | Your income varies, sometimes when you least want it to |
| Lower starting withdrawal rate | Take a smaller share of the portfolio each year | Less to spend in every year, including good ones |
| Gradual shift to bonds near retirement | Lower the stock share in the risk zone | Lower expected growth; bonds can fall too |
| Pre-set drawdown rule | Move stocks to T-Bills after a set fall and re-enter on a set condition | Gaps, selling near a low, missed rebounds and taxes |
Source: Investor.gov guidance on time horizon, risk tolerance and asset allocation; TreasuryDirect on Treasury bills.
How to check your own exposure
Five minutes with your own numbers tells you more than any average.
- Divide your planned yearly withdrawal by your current balance. That is your withdrawal rate.
- Note how many years until withdrawals start, or how long they have been running.
- Count how many years of withdrawals you hold outside stocks today.
- Run the calculator with your own balance and withdrawal, once with losses first and once with losses last.
- If the gap would change your plans, pick now which approach from the table you would use.
How a rule can run this on Amaltash
On Amaltash, you can write the reserve and the drawdown rule in plain English. The rule above is one example. It works much like a stop-loss rule, but for a whole strategy.
When a limit you set breaks, the rule sells the holdings it covers. It moves that money into Treasury bills. Then it follows your rule for buying back in.
The rule decides in advance what happens in a bad year. It does not decide how the year turns out. Prices can gap past your limit, and the rule can sell near a low and miss a rebound. Sales in a taxable account can create a tax bill.
Test the idea first with your own withdrawals in the calculator above.
Risks and limits
- All investing involves risk of loss. No withdrawal plan guarantees your money lasts.
- Cash and T-Bill reserves earn short-term interest that can trail stocks and inflation over long periods.
- A drawdown rule can sell below its level when prices gap, sell near a low and miss the rebound, and fire repeatedly in choppy markets.
- Selling in a taxable account can create capital gains tax; Treasury Bill interest is subject to federal income tax.
Frequently asked questions
Does the 4% rule account for sequence of returns risk?
The 4% rule comes from William Bengen's 1994 study of US returns since 1926, bad starts included. There, a 4% first-year withdrawal, raised for inflation, always lasted at least 33 years. That is past data for half stocks and half Treasury notes, and future orders can be worse.
How long will my money last in retirement?
It depends on your balance, your withdrawals, your returns and their order. Run your numbers in a retirement calculator, then test a bad start here. No calculator can promise how long money lasts.
Does sequence of returns risk matter more in early retirement?
It can. An early retiree needs the money to last more years, so a poor start has longer to compound. The ways to reduce it are the same, and so are their costs.
Does a bucket strategy get rid of sequence risk?
It lowers the chance you must sell stocks in a down year, while the cash bucket lasts. A fall longer than the bucket still forces sales, and the cash earns less than stocks over time.
Is sequence of returns risk the opposite of dollar-cost averaging?
In a way. Dollar-cost averaging puts in a fixed amount, so it buys more shares when prices are low. Taking out a fixed amount does the reverse: it sells more shares when prices are low.
Sources
- Investor.gov: Time Horizon
- Investor.gov: Risk Tolerance
- Investor.gov: Beginners' Guide to Asset Allocation, Diversification, and Rebalancing
- Journal of Financial Planning: Bengen, Determining Withdrawal Rates Using Historical Data, 1994
- Amaltash index drawdown dataset (CSV, CC-BY 4.0)
- TreasuryDirect: Treasury Bills
Educational content published by Amaltash Advisors LLC. Nothing here is investment advice or a recommendation to buy or sell any security. All investing involves risk of loss, including loss of principal, and past performance does not guarantee future results.